How to Spot a Good Small Business Deal (and Avoid a Bad One)

The key is knowing to look for both the red flags that signal trouble and the green flags that indicate a solid opportunity. In this guide, we’ll walk you through how to evaluate a business deal, step by step.

Understanding what makes a business deal “good”

A good small business deal is one where you buy a profitable and sustainable business at a fair price, with clear growth potential and minimal hidden risks. It should align with your financial goals, expertise, and risk tolerance. Before signing any deal, ask yourself:

• Does this business fit my skills and experience?
  
• Can I see a clear path to maintaining or increasing profitability?
  
• Are the risks manageable, and do I have a plan to mitigate them?
  

If the answer to these questions is unclear, you need to dig deeper.

Green Flags: Signs of a good small business deal

1. Strong financial health
A financially healthy business should show consistent revenue and profit. Look at:

• Revenue trends: Is income stable or growing year over year?
  
• Profit margins: Are they reasonable for the industry?
  
• Debt levels: Does the business carry a manageable level of debt?
  

Tip: Always request at least three years of financial statements and tax returns to verify.

2. Clear and documented operations
A business that runs smoothly without heavy owner involvement is a positive sign. Check for:

• Standard operating procedures (SOPs)
  
• A strong, experienced team in place
  
• Reliable supplier and vendor relationships
  

If the business falls apart without the owner, it may not be worth buying.

3. A loyal customer base
A business with repeat customers and strong brand loyalty is more stable. Look at customer retention rates and online reviews. If the business heavily depends on a few key customers, that’s a risk.

4. Growth potential
Is there room to expand? Check for:

• Untapped markets or product lines
  
• Industry trends that support future demand
  
• Scalable operations
  

A stagnant business without growth potential may not be worth the investment even if it initially looks like a solid small business deal.

5. Transparent seller and clean records
A trustworthy seller provides full access to business records, legal documents, and financial statements. If the seller is hesitant or evasive, take it as a warning sign.

Red Flags: Signs of a bad business deal

1. Inconsistent or declining revenue
If revenue has been dropping for multiple years, understand why. Temporary dips can happen, but a long-term downward trend could signal deeper problems.

2. Poor financial records or hidden liabilities
If the seller can’t provide clean financial records, be cautious. Watch out for:

• Unexplained cash transactions
  
• High debt or pending lawsuits
  
• Overstated profits
  

Always conduct thorough due diligence to avoid financial surprises.

3. Owner-dependent business
Some businesses rely too much on the owner’s personal relationships or skills. If customers, suppliers, or employees might leave after the owner steps away, it’s a risk.

4. High employee turnover
Frequent staff turnover can indicate internal issues such as poor management, low morale, or financial instability. Talk to key employees if possible to gauge workplace culture.

5. Legal or compliance issues
Check for:

• Unresolved lawsuits
  
• Regulatory violations
  
• Expired licenses or missing permits

These can become costly and time-consuming to resolve after you take over.

How to protect yourself before closing a deal

Even if everything looks good on paper, take these extra steps:

1. Conduct due diligence
Hire an accountant and attorney to verify financials, contracts, and legal standing. You can use SMB.co's growth network to find one near you!

2. Negotiate terms wisely
Structure the deal to protect yourself. Consider:

• Earn-outs (where part of the payment is based on future performance)
  
• Seller financing (so the seller has a stake in your success)
  
• Non-compete agreements (so the seller doesn’t start a competing business)
  

3. Speak with customers and employees
Hearing firsthand experiences from customers and employees can provide insights you won’t find in documents.

4. Have an exit plan
Even before buying, think about your long-term strategy. Will you grow and sell later, or hold the business long-term? Having an exit plan ensures you buy with purpose.

So, how do you spot a good small business deal?

Spotting a good business deal takes careful evaluation, patience, and due diligence. Look for financial stability, clear operations, a loyal customer base, and growth potential. Avoid deals with hidden risks, unclear financials, or heavy owner dependency. By taking the right steps, you can secure a business that offers long-term success.

‍